 |
Grilled Oysters |
Last night was a delightful preview of autumn here in Indianapolis, so we ate grilled oysters outside, a la Drago’s Restaurant in Fat City, near where I grew up. Fat City is a little area of Metairie, a suburb of New Orleans, that’s mostly restaurants and bars. I’m not sure if it’s still called Fat City, or why it ever was so named, but anybody that grew up in New Orleans knows the part of town I’m talking about. Drago’s is famous for their char-grilled oysters, which have become a menu item de rigueur in The Big Easy. I experimented with the recipe years ago, and now have my own version of it, which we do occasionally as a treat, since Derek is batpoo crazy about oysters. I’m so lucky that we can get fresh oysters at our neighborhood Kroger, and that Derek is willing and able to shuck them if I make the sauce.
A few months ago, we had some friends over for dinner and they brought their 13-year-old daughter with them. Poor darling; her plans for the night had gone awry and I’m sure she was not thrilled to be spending her precious Saturday evening with her parents and a couple of old geezers she had never met. The menu had not exactly been designed with a teen in mind and I was a little worried she wouldn’t like anything I had prepared, although her mother assured me that August was not a picky eater. Grilled oysters were the first course, and to my surprise and delight, August was more than game to try them. As it turned out, she loved them as much as Derek and I do, which tickled me to death. It’s a great pleasure and a compliment to introduce a new dish to someone who really enjoys it. A few days later I was pleasantly surprised to receive a thank-you note in the mail from her mom – when was the last time someone sent you a handwritten thank-you note for dinner?

This is how you prepare two dozen grilled oysters (my measurements, as always, are approximate): First you have to find someone who will shuck them - and good luck with that! I’ve tried using shucked oysters and putting them in muffin tins on the grill. That was a drastic error; the muffin tins were too deep and the oysters ended up steamed instead of grilled - not appetizing at all. I suppose you could save some old oyster shells, clean them really well and re-use them, and I’ve often thought about doing just that, but there’s something very special about just-shucked oysters. I'm a big believer in delaying gratification.
Mince 5 or more large toes of garlic, a handful of fresh Italian parsley and about half a teaspoon of fresh rosemary – the rosemary should be barely detectable and just add a mysterious depth of flavor to the oysters. Grate about a cup of Parmigiano Reggiano; it’s important to use really good quality cheese in this dish, as there are so few ingredients – please do not use that sawdust in a green can! Heat the garlic in a combination of ¼ stick (2 Tablespoons) of butter and an equal amount of Extra Virgin Olive Oil, just until it’s fragrant. I usually do this in a glass measuring cup in the microwave, but you can do it on the stove as well. If you have any of the mixture left, it’s great on grilled bread, which is what I did last night. Spoon about a teaspoon of the garlic/butter/olive oil mixture over each shucked oyster, still in its shell. Sprinkle with a little fresh grated Parmigiano Reggiano, a little parsley and just a tiny sprinkle of rosemary. Place the oysters in their shells on a metal cookie sheet and place on a super hot grill. Close the grill and cook them for just a few minutes, until the oysters are just ruffled on the edges. With a green salad, some bread (I prefer warm New Orleans French bread) and a cool crisp white wine, you have a meal made in heaven.